Last year, I wrote an article called “Martha’s Gift” which dealt with the extremely difficult topic of understanding the “why” of someone taking their own life. Martha’s mom is still having a very difficult time of it. That is understandable. We all want to help, protect her from more harm and help her recover her life as much as possible.
But sometimes, in our need to be protect and help the vulnerable after such a tragedy, we can forget the basic virtues of love, kindness and mercy we should have towards others. Regardless. And while we may think we are doing the right thing, we end-up being very, very wrong and doing the very thing we accuse someone else of doing.
“Do As I Say”—one of the “you don’t know what you don’t know” stories--is this.
As I’ve said, Martha’s mom, let’s call her Michelle, is still riddled with grief. Michelle is struggling to get back on her horse, move forward, sort out what life means after this great loss. Always active in her church, Martha had signed up to resume her role at Sts. Simon and Jude being a Eucharistic Minister. As she was driving one Saturday morning, the day before resuming her duties, a series of things happened quickly, almost all at once—a loud bang, an ambulance, police car sirens—that brought a tsunami of horrific memories and visuals and Michelle was drowning again in sorrow and grief. Unable to drive, she pulled off the road and sat until she able to continue.
When she got home, she realized that she had committed to being at Mass early the next day. Too upset to talk on the phone, she sent an email to one of the people involved in scheduling, Alison, and said she could not help-out on Sunday for personal reasons. The reply was something like, “Well, this is such short notice. I wish you had let me know a little ahead for time so I could find a substitute.” Snarky.
The next day, Michelle and her husband came over to our house, and she was telling us that she was not ready to get back into church activities and, before she could complete outlining her thought process, she fell apart, broke down and could barely speak. She told us what happened and Alison’s response.
I was outraged. How dare that woman react that way. Alison knew that Michelle had lost her daughter several years earlier. Shouldn’t she have been more understanding? Shouldn’t she have thought that maybe there’s was something else going on? She doesn’t understand what just happened to Michelle and, in any event, should she not have assumed that there was something she didn’t know? As I have said and written about, “You don’t know what you don’t know” and isn’t it the Christian, compassionate thing to give the benefit of the doubt? Unlike what I should have done, I couldn’t say enough bad about Alison.
We comforted Michelle, she got herself back together, we affirmed her decision, talked about the limitations of emails versus phone calls, and had a very nice rest of the afternoon.
But wait, I thought later on. True, Alison had not been very nice to Michelle in her email. I thought the worst of her, justifiably in my mind, that she was an insensitive, nasty, very un-Christian person. But in my rush to support Michelle, had I not just done the very same thing that I had accused Alison of? Heck, I didn’t know what happened to her that day. Maybe her mom was sick. Maybe she was waiting for a test result. Maybe her husband stayed out to all hours and came home drunk the night before. Maybe she was worried about not having enough money for groceries. Maybe she was just tired. Or having a bad day. Maybe, just maybe, there was a very good reason for Alison not sending a more sensitive and thoughtful email. And even if there wasn’t a good reason, shouldn’t I have been more understanding and forgiving? I was dead right. While protecting Michelle, I was doing the very same thing I was accusing Alison of.
It is hard to give others the benefit of the doubt. But it is really, really hard when someone does something very obviously wrong. In Michelle’s state of mind and heart, that email seemed to be the work of a nasty person. But maybe it was just the result of her having a nasty day. It’s not good. But that doesn’t mean Alison is bad. We all sin.
Regardless of the degree of the offense, Christ calls us not to judge, to give everyone the benefit of the doubt, and to have mercy and compassion regardless. Doing the wrong thing in the right situation, being dead right, is not the model Jesus laid-out for us.
The model He laid-out for us, is this:
As He was dying on the cross, Jesus said, “Forgive them, Father. They know not what they are doing.”
I should, we should be like that. Do as I say, not as I do. Mea culpa.
Show A Little Faith.

